Michael Carrick and Roy Keane: so dissimilar and yet so alike

Author: Doron

Follow Doron on Twitter

A metronome performs the same action at regular intervals. It is both reliable and predictable. If one were to describe a footballer as ‘metronomic’ you could be forgiven for assuming this implies dullness or that the player has limitations. Yet it feels like exactly the right word to describe probably the most important midfielder at United, Michael Carrick – this team’s Roy Keane.

Fresh from arguably his best and most understated performance for the club he’s continuing to prove that his assets are plentiful. Asked, as he often is, to sit in front of United’s defence, Carrick was a nuisance for City. With Cleverley, Rooney and the wingers working hard to pick men up, Carrick was able to concentrate on simply being in the right place at the right time to make a block, tackle or interception.

Having inherited Keane’s old number and being signed the summer after Roy left United, there was, wrongly or rightly, always going to be a level of expectation associated with Carrick. Having a style on the pitch that was really quite dissimilar to Roy’s didn’t help nor did a performance in Rome in the Champions League final. (Mind you, Carrick himself thinks he did ok in that game and to be honest, it felt at the time that he was simply singled out as a scapegoat for a bad performance). Still, it’s fair to suggest that it’s taken Carrick a little while to truly find his niche in the team.

Carrick critics always seem to go to one place more than any other – where he passes the ball. Maybe it’s because United’s midfield has lacked quality in recent years or because fans struggle to see the value in keeping possession over a high-risk pass forwards but it’s always been an odd thing to hold against a player when the numbers have never quite proven it’s the case. More to the point, United are a side who often seek inspiration and craft from out wide so distribution of the ball sideways makes sense for a central player.

It’s therefore rather amusing to read that Carrick has played more forward passes than any other player in the league this season. That said, you can actually explain that quite rationally – Carrick’s role, even in a two man midfield tends to be a deep one, therefore the majority of the time everything is happening ahead of him. Still, plenty of players play a similar kind of role at other clubs and yet Carrick is still the one to come out on top. Sure, he may not score or assist as much as he should but you can be certain he’ll have played a big part in many of the clubs best moves, often playing a vital pass pre-assist.

Even if passing stats for Carrick are pretty, they’re arguably not the most valuable part of what he does. There is a scary consistency about nearly everything he else, to a point where a player once associated with passing, is now associated with positioning – a different kind of awareness. His uncanny knack of being right where opponents don’t want him to be makes him invaluable to United. Time and time again he’s the man doing the hard and dirty work yet in a manner so graceful that it’s often unnoticed. His ability to anticipate a dangerous situation makes you wonder if he’s got a built in early-warning system.

Actually, a comparison with the great Roy Keane is probably as apt as it ever has been. Not because of their style or in the sense of leadership. Rather, Carrick’s made himself invaluable to the side through his intelligence and sheer repetitiveness of every single thing he does – his role in the team makes him a guaranteed starter almost every game. Whether it’s a pass or tackle you can be sure that it’s almost always perfectly executed to the highest level. His perfect partner is arguably yet to be found but putting energy and dynamism around him appears to be the best route for a generally underwhelming midfield. In fact, Keane in his pomp would probably thrive playing with the Carrick of today.

Somewhere there is an irony in all this. Carrick was signed to replace Roy but was nothing like Roy and yet now there are actually similarities between the two. With maturity, he’s given the ‘16’ shirt a new and different meaning – one of intelligence and calculations as opposed to fearsomeness and noise but ball retention, reliability, consistency and a sense of being invaluable remains. He could never be Roy and never tried to be but simply had to be given time for fans to appreciate him for what he is. It’s not uncommon to see him subtly dominate a midfield, just as he did on Sunday at Man City but like Scholes, he won’t be bothered if others are singled out for praise head of him (as they were). Although quiet, he still has the same determination and passion (just look at how he celebrates goals) that Roy had – Michael gets United. It’s just bizarre that United fans have struggled to get Carrick for so long and England are still struggling.

Fortunately, with age, Carrick’s getting better rather than starting to descend over the far side of his peak. Just like any good metronome, you know exactly what to expect from Carrick every time he goes on the pitch. He’s ensured that one can say with near enough complete certainty, United will at some point in the next few years once again have to face the monumental challenge of replacing their number sixteen.

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 9.0/10 (83 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: +15 (from 17 votes)
Michael Carrick and Roy Keane: so dissimilar and yet so alike, 9.0 out of 10 based on 83 ratings

8 Responses to “Michael Carrick and Roy Keane: so dissimilar and yet so alike”

  1. Rajiv says:

    Wow!!!!,

    Was actually waiting for something like this on Michael Carrick.

    He has kept ticking the midfield for the past 3-4 years now. Pair him with Anderson, and I believe that people will finally stop moaning for a quality Midfield.

    Great piece of Article.

    Cheers!!!

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (7 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +8 (from 10 votes)
  2. Hanif says:

    Absolutely spot on. This is exactly what I was thinking

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (4 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +5 (from 7 votes)
  3. Fordyce says:

    Top drawer article. Everything about Carrick rightly said, this article would be alot more perfect if there were statistics and evidences to show his ability,only to further convince the haters.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +2 (from 6 votes)
  4. Gerard says:

    Absolutely spot on. The guy gets ignored so often which is so unfair because he’s been pretty invaluble to our team for a long time. Highlights on motd will never do Carrick justice. I’m constantly pointing out his good work to mates to try and get them to realise how important he is.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 4.5/5 (2 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +4 (from 6 votes)
  5. Phil says:

    Just like Denis Irwin many years ago, Carrick is a player of such high consistency, his good games go unnoticed because they are the norm.

    Also like Irwin, a suitable nickname could be ‘Mr 8 out of 10′ – Rarely reach the heights of 10/10 performances but you’ll almost never see him play anything less than a 7.

    Invaluable indeed.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +5 (from 7 votes)
  6. […] Stretford-End- Michael Carrick and Roy Keane […]

  7. Spot on. Always an easy target but SAF plays him and has done for years now. He plays the game in a un-english style that some people don’t like whereas I would say that it is a compliment. Skills, vision, awareness, technical ability & composure. Nowt wrong with that.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 4.7/5 (3 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +4 (from 4 votes)
  8. […] Doron Salomon, amazed that it has taken so long for United fans to ‘get’ Carrick, doesn’t answer the question, but believes the Reds will soon face a new task: replacing a Carrick-shaped hole in the midfield. Salomon shares some thoughts on United’s metronome in “Michael Carrick and Roy Keane: so dissimilar and yet so alike”, Stretty Rant: […]

  9. Trevor Jones says:

    I’ve also been defending Carrick for ages with other United fans. The man is unbelievable and definitely one of the most underrated players in the game. The argument seems to be “well if he’s that good, then how come he doesn’t play for England (often)” which is just ridiculous considering I would take SAF’s opinion of Carrick over any of the managers who have made the calls for England over the years. And the thing is, is that finally England is starting to recognize just how good he is. Personally, I think that Carrick can step into any team in the world and he wouldn’t miss a beat. Carrick’s biggest problem is that he’s Enlgish. If he was Spanish he would be considered one of the best in the world like Alonso or Bisquets…

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (1 vote cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: -1 (from 1 vote)
  10. […] Then there’s Carrick. After a summer of fawning over Pirlo, fans and pundits suddenly realised that Carrick’s actually alright. Having played more forward passes than any other midfielder this season and been arguably United’s most undroppable player he’s finally had some much warranted recognition. Still, arguably his most important contributions are defensive – intercepting, tackling, clearing, blocking – simply reading the game so incredibly well. However, you can imagine that your average football fan would scrunch up his face if you tried to suggest that Carrick had been so good. Such a clean player, one who excels at the simple things, really isn’t appreciated unless he plays for Barcelona. […]

  11. idris azeez says:

    Well articulated! I’v never seen a complete player with high sense of intelligent as carrick does. He is a tiki taka kind of player. He would have been successful with Spanish or Barcelona team. I always likened him to Busquets even to me a more better passer than Busquets, but he is an English player. Until he retires, then United will recognise his ability.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

Leave a Reply