Who do you see as van der Sar’s replacement?

van der Sar

Edwin van der Sar has been a colossus player for Manchester United since signing from Fulham five years ago.  Sir Alex Ferguson has publicly acknowledged the difficulty in replacing Peter Schmeichel, after the Danish keeper left for Sporting Lisbon in the summer of 1999, and conceded that United should have since the Dutchman then.  The former Ajax man signed for Juventus  the day before Sir Alex made contact in 99 and United had to settle on Mark Bosnich, who was available on a free transfer.   Eric Steele believes that the Dutchman will hang up his gloves at the end of the season – but who do you think could replace him?


United have been linked with numerous keepers over the past few months, with a ludicrously absurd story linking Pepe Reina with a move to Old Trafford. Fergie will be conscious of previous history in recruiting goalkeepers after a legendary keeper leaves. He has also paid tribute to the ability of van der Sar, putting him in the same bracket as Schmeichel:

“I tried to replace Schmeichel, but that was very difficult. We went for Fabien Barthez and he did well for a while, but he then had his own situations, so we went for Edwin. We really should have gone for him when Schmeichel left, but [former chairman] Martin Edwards had an agreement with Mark Bosnich at the time that took the wind out of our sails. So we couldn’t get Edwin, but I’d have loved to have got him then. He is different entirely to Schmeichel and you can’t compare them, but there was a certain criteria to be a goalkeeper here which involved good experience, personality and also a good track record. Edwin has all of those qualities. He didn’t cost us a lot of money, about £2 million, so he’s right up there with my best signings.”

I do agree with Ferguson about Barthez that he “did well for a while”, but he made some horrendous blunders that costs United in big games. I still believe that he was at fault for at least two of Real Madrid’s three goals in the 4-3 victory back in the spring of 2003 (Ronaldo’s first and last if I remember rightly). I blogged two years ago about United’s goalkeeper crisis and have to say that I maybe had my red tinted specs on a little and didn’t really give credit to what a fine goalkeeper van der Sar actually is. My original blog was probably in defense of Fergie’s decision to pluck Barthez, a World Cup winner, from AS Monaco and highlight his impressive debut season.

Reading the article in the Telegraph that discussed Fergie’s late call to the Dutchman in June 99, it is clear to see that van der Sar was extremely close to a move to Old Trafford after leaving Ajax. His inevitable departure to Fulham in 2001, following the Old Lady’s purchase of Gianluigi Buffon from Parma, saw United miss out on his signature again due to the impressive debut season of Barthez. Eventually Fergie brought the Dutchman to Old Trafford, despite using ten goal keepers in the previous six years. Bosnich, van der Gouw, Culkin, Taibi, Rachubka, Barthez, Goram, Carroll, Ricardo and Tim Howard. Sure, you could argue that five of those keepers were never first choice – but the consistency of van der Sar since 2005 has highlighted the quality of our number one over the previous ten keepers.

So to the candidates:

David De Gea – Only 19, Fergie and Steele reportedly went to Spain to watch the young keeper in action against Valencia last month. Possible target but expect Atletico to get numerous offers.

Manuel Neuer – Schalke keeper who established himself as Germany’s number one in the summer. Long been linked with a move to Bayern Munich, the 24 year old is a less likely replacement for van der Sar.

Anders Lindegaard – Regarded as the heir to Schmeichel’s Danish crown, although at 26 has only accumulated 2 caps. United scouts have reportedly been monitoring his progress closely over the past few weeks.

Maarten Stekelenburg – van der Sar’s replacement in the national team and could well follow suit for United also. The oldest of the candidates and out of contract in the summer of 2012 – so could well come cheaply if Ajax believe he could walk for nothing.

Igor Akinfeev – Another player who’s contract runs out relatively soon (Dec 2011) and could be tempted with a move to Old Trafford. The CSKA Moscow skipper and Ruissan number 1 has already experienced the atmosphere at United – and has been linked to a move away.

Hugo Lloris – French number 1, the 23 year old looks the less likely of all the candidates due to the high valuation fee (reportedly £25million) Lyon have slapped on him.

So, are there any keepers I have omitted? Are any of the keepers above likely to move to Old Trafford as van der Sar’s replacement. If you were Fergie and could afford the transfer fee – who would you sign for United and why?

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

7 Responses to “Who do you see as van der Sar’s replacement?”

  1. Adam Bateman says:

    I would pick someone else, I would go for Seb Frey at Fiorentina, as he is someone that I rate very highly. He has got Champions League experience, and he is still old enough to be our number one for many a year.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  2. For me, Neuer is the safe option.

    Stekelenberg isn’t good enough; Lloris has promised a lot but makes errors; Akinfeev may be a good option but he’s not the tallest; Lindegaard is an unknown; and de Gea would be fantastic but it’s always a risk to go with youth.

    VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  3. Smid82 says:

    I think buffon would be an excellent replacement VDS if he can get over his current back problems and only just being 30 could be a good keeper for the nxt 10 yrs if he takes leaf out of VDS book

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  4. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Doron Salomon, Stretford End, rinaldi anggamara, Terence Ting Si Yuan, Terence Ting Si Yuan and others. Terence Ting Si Yuan said: RT @stretford_end: Did a blog on van der Sar replacement – http://www.stretford-end.com/blog/2010/10/who-do-you-see-as-van-der-sars-replacement/ (poll) […]

  5. @tom7p says:

    I’d go for de gea. Looks class. But Frey and Boruc should be considered too.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  6. Matt says:

    It’s got to be De Gea but I’d say Buffon would be their second choice.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  7. archanios says:

    Lindegaard is a very good keeper, a great shotstopper, pretty good on crosses and corners, and he has the ability to put the ball quickly and precisely back into play. (Aafk is my Norwegian team, so I have seen quite a lot of Lindegaard)

    The problem with him is that despite being 26 he has no real experience from a big league, having only played in Denmark and Norway. The fact that he is playing in Norway is possibly the most important reason why he only has two caps for Denmark, as he is probably their best keeper at the moment.

    I think Lindegaard would be the least expensive of the options you have listed, but even though I highly rate him as a keeper, and have seen how important he has been for Aafk in the Norwegian league and during the Norwegian Cup-win last year, he would still be sort of a gamble beacause of his lack of experience at the highest level. He could be a new Schmeichel both for a club and his country, but someone from a bigger league than the Norwegian will have to give him a chance.

    I would not mind if we tried for a youth like De Gea, but the question is if his inexperience will cause us problems. Also a question as to whether or not he will continue to evolve as he has until now. Akinfeev is a good keeper who already has a lot of xp, but he does lack a bit in the height department and I think that would be a problem in the PL. For me Steklenburg is to old, Buffon a good choice if he can keep himself fit and has the drive to keep on, while both Lloris and Neuer could be great signings. I am glad it is not my decision.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  8. […] years ago, but obviously missed out when the Dutchman moved to Juventus from Ajax in 1999. We ran a poll earlier in the season on Van Der Sar’s inevitable replacement, with David De Gea coming out as […]

  9. […] after the news that Edwin Van der Sar will retire at the end of the season. Many names have been touted around as possible replacements, including David De Gea, Manuel Neuer and Igor Akinfeev. View […]

  10. […] major and emerging Goalkeeper in Europe has been mentioned but im not going to look at them in this article. I feel it is more pertinent to […]

  11. […] Edwin retiring, who should replace him has been an ongoing debate for some time now amongst United fans and the press. It seems almost certain that David De Gea is […]

  12. United Fan says:

    Hmmm. I’m afraid David De Gea could fall into the United’s miscillaneous goalkeepers club.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

Leave a Reply