Man United 0-1 Chelsea: tactical change gifts Chelsea the win

david luiz rafael sending off

Authors: Sleepy Nik and Doron

Follow Sleepy_Nik and Doron on Twitter

United played Chelsea for a fifth and final time this season. Chelsea needed to get something from the game to keep up the pressure on Spurs ahead of their big clash on Wednesday whilst United are champions already and although they had nothing to play for, a strong side was still put out, albeit with a few changes. As ever, we welcome comments from both sets of supporters.

Fergie’s change in tactics gifts Chelsea the win

We questioned Fergie’s use of 4-4-2 after our visit to the Bridge in early April (and indeed, Vidic’s rotation given Ba’s aerial threat), so it was good to see the manager start with a central midfield trio of Jones, Cleverley and Anderson, (with Giggs in a wide left role, and Valencia in his usual right wing berth), in what was essentially a 4-5-1. This allowed United to match Lampard, Ramires and the floating Mata in the centre (with Chelsea operating a typical 4-3-3 formation), and both systems were very fluid in attacking transitions, with both teams attacking in numbers – especially with both sets of fullbacks as ambitious as ever.

Importantly with this formation, Jones was able to shield the area in between the lines, where the likes of Mata and Oscar liked to drop into, and his anticipation was good for the most part. Anderson played just to the right of centre, with Cleverley to the left, and both sought to link the play with van Persie – more often than not by carrying the ball into the final third, taking the opportunity to burst through the centre where possible. Their defensive pressing was also a feature, and the game seemed destined to end goalless. However, the landscape changed on 68 minutes when Ferguson replaced Anderson and Cleverley for Buttner and Rooney, as United reverted to a 4-4-1-1 shape, with Giggs joining Jones in the centre and the Dutchman playing wide left. Jones’ shielding role was no longer, as he sought to attack when United had the ball and press high on Lampard when without it, ultimately leaving lots of space behind him and Giggs.

With Moses and Oscar swapping channels throughout the game, and Ba often coming deep to pull Vidic out, Mata inevitably began to see more of the ball and was able to get in behind United’s defensive line on occasion. Chelsea responded to the United change by swapping Moses for Torres on the left side, presumably as Rafael and Valencia were linking well in attacking areas, leaving space behind. Chelsea sensed the disorganisation and pressed much higher in the last quarter of the game, with Ramires in particular dominating the centre. In fact, it was the Brazilian who tracked back to thwart Rooney, before driving through the big space in United’s middle, and he flicked it back to Oscar who sumptuously deceived Evans and Vidic with a cute pass into Mata’s path. Jones initially had Mata marked, but was dragged inside to Torres which opened up the shooting opportunity. Though deflected, Lindegaard will be disappointed in his starting position, as he was unable to palm the ball clear.

Whilst the title has long been won, and Fergie rightly rotated his team for this game, there is still a sense of disappointment in terms of the lack of focus and output on display today – and in particular after 70 minutes. Fergie wanted to give Buttner some game time, and Rooney’s entrance should rather have been the attacking impetus we needed, rather than the tactical faux-pas it turned out to be; but there is no doubt that the reversion to two in the middle assisted Chelsea here. Giggs and Jones were simply passed by and were unable to press as a duo and United withdrew deeper and deeper as the game was stretched. Not as galling as the defeat in the FA Cup, but a defeat that saw Chelsea step closer to that Champions League spot, and one that put an end to United’s 67 game stretch of scoring in consecutive games staged at Old Trafford.

Rafael’s red

It seems more than likely that Rafael’s season is now over unless United decide to appeal against his red card for kicking out at David Luiz. Howard Webb came to the right conclusion over the incident and sent Rafael off. Webb’s job was unquestionably made easier by Luiz’s reaction to the incident – although Rafael kicked out, Luiz decided to jump up as if shot before hitting the ground, having a laugh and checking to see what was going on before rolling around again. In theory he’d done little wrong other than play-act to ensure Chelsea’s numerical advantage – had he gotten straight up, maybe Rafael wouldn’t have been sent off when he should have been.

Here’s what Fergie had to say on it:

“He [Da Silva] retaliates but Luiz quite clearly elbows him twice, then rolls about like a diving swan and that convinces the referee. He was smiling. It’s bad. What kind of professional is that? …It was rash what he [Da Silva] did, he’s a young lad and should know better but retaliation never works.”

Luiz has quickly been heralded as a hero by Chelsea fans on the internet. Mind you, I don’t remember them enjoying the play-acting of a certain ball-boy quite so much…

Middle men

Anderson and Cleverley were brought into the starting line up after fairly lengthy spells away from it. Maybe harshly from Fergie they were expected to perform against one of the league’s best sides despite weeks and months out of the team. Not an easy ask at all.

Both would have benefited from Carrick’s presence behind them, a safety net that could allow them to push on with even more authority. Alas, it never quite seemed to work today. Often there was only van Persie ahead of them – too often isolated and forced to hold the ball up. When attacking they took different routes: Anderson opted to try and make some of the lower percentage passes work – ambitious balls over the top; whereas Cleverley was less risky, focussing on linking play over shorter distances.

Neither are particularly physical players but Anderson did try to put himself about, he just had little luck, coming off as the loser in many 50:50s. Cleverley’s shown more than enough this season to reaffirm he has a future at the club (incredible to think that’s even debated) whilst Anderson, although maybe needing to move on for his own career, may not be let go unless two central players are brought in to both improve the starting XI and add some depth.

Chelsea just won’t burn

For all the mocking Benitez gets, he now has a settled side and is getting results. It’s painful to have to give him any kind of praise, as I’m sure Chelsea fans are all too aware, but he deserves some. Somehow his players haven’t burnt out yet – Oscar is playing off the back of the Olympics and yet has clocked up over 60 appearances this season for example.

Benitez has learnt that he simply hasn’t got quality in depth that can allow him to make wholesale changes to rest player but his tweaking it now and then has paid off. Mata, Oscar and Hazard have all been given the odd game off whilst Luiz’s versatility has been made good use of. Should Chelsea draw on Wednesday against Spurs, a top four place should be theirs to go along with the Europa League final and FA Cup semi final. Chelsea fans will be loathe to praise him but a top four finish will be an improvement on last year when Di Matteo was also trying to balance out numerous competitions; and, it could of course see the return of Mr Mourinho.


After playing a strong side against Arsenal last week, Spurs fans in particular might have been hoping for more of the same again. To their disappointment, Fergie chopped and changed, removing three of United’s key players this season – Ferdinand, Carrick and de Gea. If last week he felt he had a duty to play his strongest side for the sake of the Champions League chasing teams, he’d had a change of heart this week.

Lindegaard managed to tip Oscar’s effort onto the post but otherwise it had been a quiet first half, albeit one Chelsea had been the better side in. The second half followed a similar pattern until Fergie altered the shape of United and Chelsea started to create openings as the game became more stretched. Mata’s winning goal was heading wide until it clipped Phil Jones; even so Lindegaard might have felt he could do better. The Danish keeper had a mixed game – some assertive catches and solid saves but plenty of flapping too and then maybe needed to do better at the crucial point in the game. For Chelsea, Mata was the one making things tick yet again. He’s undoubtedly been one of the league’s best players this season and is so vital to Chelsea as the stats prove.

The game ended on a low point for United as Rafael was sent off for kicking out at David Luiz who made sure that the referee know he’d been touched. It was a disappointing performance and sadly something that’s become all too familiar of late. The title may be decided but fans turned up to be entertained, not to watch players traipse around the pitch and offer very little in the way of attacking football. Swansea next week is the final home game of the season and will hopefully provide a few youngsters with a chance to play as well as maybe a farewell to a certain ginger.

NB: the goal has been officially given as a Phil Jones OG

12 Comments on Man United 0-1 Chelsea: tactical change gifts Chelsea the win

  1. There are rumors swirling on Facebook that, Sir Alex lost to Chelsea so that Spurs would miss out on the CL spot and then Bale would leave Spurs.

    Shame if it turns out to be true.

  2. I thought Anderson was pretty good. By far the best midfielder anyway, strong and positive as he always is and he’s so much more interesting to watch than our other midfielders. Evans had a cracking match too. Giggs, Cleverley and Valencia were shocking.

  3. “A strong side was still put out” ha.
    Hated this game more than any other game this season. Garbage! Valencia! What is up with that guy?! Bloody hell. Cleverley?! Hmm. Average sprongs to mind. Squad player at best.
    Ando. Ok. Nothing more, nothing less. Vidic our best player! By a mile! Absolute beast!
    Quicker these 2 games finsish the better! I’m over this season. Been some highs but more lows in fairness. Winning the league was massive though and ill take it for sure! Just hope this cm issue is dealt with and put to bed in the summer once and for all. I highly doubt it’ll happen though. Fergie thinks otherwise. Oh well, what’ll be will be but still…
    Play the kids vs Swansea? If I was SAF I’d play my strongest team. No point playing the kids, lose and have to lift the trophy on a low. Win the game! Play a strong side and finished! What’s the point really in playing the kids with 2 games to go? False hope for them really when next season comes and they’re shunted back into the 21’s with no real chance at getting a crack at the 1st team. I don’t get excited by youth team and reserve team players at this club anymore to be honest. We have some unreal talent coming through but what’s the point really? Ha, Fergie talking up Januzaj! For what ha? As if the kid will be given the chance to come through?! As if Davide Petrucci, larnell Cole, Jesse Lingard, 2 Keanes, Mats Daehli, Vermijl etc will be givena real chance!? Fergie should stop talking about Januzaj, stop signing players that aren’t needed like jones in all fairness, powell, young, zaha, rvp as well and start rebuilding the team properley! And that starts with midfield! Honestly sick of him taking the piss out of us fans week in and week out by talking such bollocks! #leaveiteyeah. #pissedoffRed

  4. Fergie should stop running his mouth every now and then and concentrate on building a real modern team. We may have won the league but I’ll keep maintaining that he should retire..there’s no place for 4-4-2 in modern soccer-the main reason we’ve always struggled in Europe.
    How do you take Ando off(the only player driving the ball forward for us) and leave a 39yr old winger and a defender to play in midfield?
    Fergie is a master of ruining the ‘modern’ midfielder’s career. He’s wrecked Ando’s career by changing his playing position and the same is about to happen to Kagawa. Cleverley was once a promising lad but he’s been played in a lot of positions you can’t even tell his best position now. I pretty much fear for the likes of Petrucci,Januzaj and Powel.
    Why did we even buy Jones and Young?..he just bought them so they couldnt go to Liverpool. Bought so many useless player instead of strengthening the midfield.
    We’ll never win another UCL with Fergie unless he goes home or gets an assistant who understands modern 4-3-3 / 4-2-3-1 soccer, coz he clearly only understands old school soccer.

  5. We’re champions, so how can we moan? I’m going to have a good go…
    It’s harsh to judge some of the players out there, because the spine of the team hadn’t played for so long. Ando and Cleverley in particular, I cant remember when they last played.
    After today though, you can see why. Anderson is terrible!! He gives the ball away too often for a CM, it’s incredibly frustrating. Cleverley is just a really average player, he’s fine to have a squad player, but he’s never going to be 1st team every week. His passing is pretty average, but his shooting…. Fuck me, one of them yesterday he put in row ZZ!! It was sunday league, and frankly I expect more. We’re Manchester United for fucks sake. We should have world class players in the centre that the world envy – he’s back up so maybe I’m being harsh, but I’d much rather see Nick Powell in there, who has natural ability that way surpasses anything Cleverley will ever have.
    Overall I was gutted from the output of yesterday. It really looks like our season finished 2 weeks ago, and we’re just making up the numbers, a terrible habit to take into pre season and next season.
    By the way, what happened to Van Persie taking corners? Giggs has always taken shit corners! We scored loads early in the season because of Van Persie’s corners, but now Giggs is taking them, hitting the first man every time. Madness!

  6. clereverley is proper shit player what he is good at except that heis “LOCAL LAD”??united is so average – we got beaten by every proper team this year.. next year will be massacre for us especially if that clown fergie still be our coach..

  7. Can all of the stupid people who commented above, please piss off and support city or Chelsea. The real fans know we have the best manager in the world and by far the best team in the country. A cm to replace Anderson and another exciting winger and united will be stronger next season

  8. If anything, this game showed how much Michael Carrick does for the team – his exclusion certainly contributed to a flat performance. The 4-5-1 shape was also quite prohibitive – United stifled Chelsea’s drive in midfield but were unable to create many chances in the first 40 minutes.

    Cleverley’s talent is there for all to see but yesterday he looked rusty – he hadn’t started a PL match since February before this one and I think it showed; some of his longer passes were wayward… unusual for him. I don’t know if his body shape would allow it but if they put him on a bulk-up programme in the off-season he would be a decent candidate to partner Carrick in CM – he links up play with the forwards well, but battles against more physical midfielders.

    At the moment the talk is all about transitioning: getting back and defending in an organised manner, obtaining possession and then breaking forward in numbers. That requires CMs who can anticipate the play, intercept, and then lead the drive upfield, and Michael Carrick is one part of that but at the moment, both Cleverley and Ando have skills which ideally should be combined into a single player/position in midfield. That’s the kind of player I think United need to bring in: an energetic midfielder with drive and a turn of speed who can link up play well. Think Phil Jones’ energy with Cleverley’s skill on the ball. Sadly, (and I hate not letting sleeping dogs lie) we actually had someone who could become that player in Paul Pogba.

  9. What should have happened is us mauling Chelsea so they lose out CL next season and that I believe would really spiral the club out of control.

    The problem is that Fergie has become too comfortable in the PL.. he doesn’t really have a challenge.
    CIty beat us on points..well, let’s just get a striker that will put in a few more goals and and will win again next year. This maybe enough to win the PL but will take us nowhere in Europe. We need to improve on a large scale, whether it’s bringing up some youth (was hoping the remaining 4 games would provide exactly that) but at the same time buying 2 new established and proven world class midfielders and an established world class winger. Perhaps having Murino come to the PL wil be the push SAF requires. With the spending he’d have at his disposal at either Chelsea or City, and actually knowing how to manage vs the other moron’s at the helm at both of these clubs, this will force SAF to rethink his strategy.

    If Murino goes to Chelsea, expect only Oscar, Mata, Hazard, Cech, and Ivanovic to remain. He would build on that and it would prove to be a lethal squad. We would HAVE TO change at that point.

    I hope to God Chicharito will never end up in leading their line or we would be in serious trouble.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.